My Two Cents: Other Issues to Learn from an MA Lawyer's Misconduct - Don't be Lazy and Hit “Reply all” in Your Emails - Check Your Work!

by not proofing your e-mail before just “replying all,” you can create a slew of ethics issues for yourself! 😱

In Massachusetts, a lawyer faced public reprimand after inappropriately advising a bankruptcy attorney to ignore a court's call. The lawyer, defending a company and its owner in a pretrial hearing, suggested the possibility of a bankruptcy filing to the court. However, during the session, he covertly emailed and texted the bankruptcy lawyer with the message "Don't pick up your phone," an act he didn't disclose to the judge but accidentally revealed to opposing counsel by including him in the email to the bankruptcy lawyer. This action breached multiple professional conduct rules, leading to his reprimand. So, what lessons can we learn from this (aside from not engaging in conduct that is prejudicial to the administration of justice)?

From this story, attorneys can learn the critical importance of attentiveness when managing email communications. Notably, we should:

1. Be wary of the "reply all" function to avoid inadvertently sharing information with unintended recipients.

2. Always confirm the recipient list before sending sensitive information.

3. Understand that digital communications are not private and can be disclosed in court.

4. Recognize that actions taken in the heat of the moment can have serious professional consequences.

5. Keep in mind the ethical implications and rules of professional conduct when communicating during legal proceedings.

practical e-mail management can help create a more peaceful and ethically compliant law practice! 😀

I think the most important lesson is to always check your work before submitting it! I am not encouraging lawyers to be deceptive in their work, break laws, or not follow the rules of ethics.  But a lot of these problems (aside from his unethical behavior) would have been prevented if the lawyer just proofread his work (including who he was sending his work to) before he sent it. 🙄

My Two Cents: Attorneys can limit client expectations in the world of 24/7 e-mail.

Set client expectations early with how and when you use e-mail!

E-mail can be a godsend for attorneys. E-mail messages offer attorneys the benefits of time efficiency and convenience. With e-mail, attorneys can quickly communicate with clients and colleagues without the need for a physical meeting or phone call. E-mails can also be sent and received at any time, allowing attorneys to work outside of traditional business hours. Additionally, e-mails provide a written record of communication that can be easily referenced in the future. Many benefits can be weighed down by unintended consequences.

It is important to set boundaries and expectations with your clients from the start. That does not mean we don't work nights and weekends. After a long day or long week, it's great to clear out your e-mail inbox after dinner or a Saturday afternoon. When clients and colleagues get e-mails at any hour on any day, it creates the expectation that we are available all day, all week. I don't think we really want this, as we are entitled to some personal time.

Its nice to get a handle on e-mail communications during quiet evenings and weekends … but take measures so client’s don’t expect immediate results 24/7!

To help keep the illusion that I don't work 24/7, I use a program called Mailbutler (Mac and Windows and can be used in Outlook, G-Mail, and Apple Mail).  It allows me to write e-mails and then schedule them to send later, e.g., the next workday. There are many similar programs like this, and many of the e-mail client programs are beginning to bake this into the software. (Just be careful you don't have to keep the program open in order for the send later function to work!)

Granted, e-mail has become a preferred method of communication for attorneys due to the expectations of our clients and colleagues, but it does not mean you cannot limit expectations while getting some work done behind the scenes!         

MTC.

Happy Lawyering!!!