MTC: Why Is AI Slop Still Front-Page News in Law? 🚨 A Florida Bar Referral, the ABA Model Rules, and What Every Lawyer Must Do Now!

🚨 why are lawyers still using ai slop?!

I keep hoping the AI-hallucination story has run its course. 📰 Then another court opinion lands, and the headline writes itself again. The newest example comes from Joseph A. Corsmeier, whose Lawyer Ethics Alert post, "Florida Appeals court refers lawyer to The Florida Bar for investigation related to AI generated "slop" in court documents," should stop every practitioner mid-scroll. 🛑

So why is AI slop in the practice of law still front-page news in late 2026? After years of warnings, sanctions, and CLEs, it is a fair question.

What Happened in Florida ⚖️

According to Joseph, Florida's Fourth District Court of Appeal issued an opinion on October 21, 2026, referring a lawyer to the Florida Bar for investigation and potential discipline. The case arose from a marriage dissolution involving parenting, visitation, and a guardian ad litem.

The court's September 16 order had already denied the lawyer's petition for a writ of prohibition. It also ordered her to show cause why she should not be sanctioned. The court described her filings as lengthy, unfocused, confusing, and at times inconsistent with the record. The volume was striking. 📚 There was a 41-page request for multiple forms of relief. There was an 11-page emergency motion and three motions in limine. There was a 33-page motion to disqualify the trial judge. The petition itself ran 61 pages. Her response to the show-cause order ran 82 pages.

Here is the detail I cannot get past. The court noted that the cited cases existed. This was not a classic fake-citation case. Yet the motion to disqualify contained a lengthy false quotation attributed to a decision of that very court. The lawyer called it "human error" from drafting under "time pressure." The court responded: "Until AI, and until this case, we never encountered lawyers 'hallucinating' non-existent quotations." 😳

The line that should concern all of us came at the end: "That counsel believes her practice in this case is acceptable raises many issues that the Florida Bar should consider."

Why Is This Still Happening? 🤔

Lawyers who use AI have the Duty to Verify Every Court Filing 🔎

I have written about this problem repeatedly, from "Why Are Lawyers Still Failing at AI Legal Research? The Alarming Rise of AI Hallucinations in Courtrooms" to "MTC: AI Hallucinated Cases Are Now Shaping Court Decisions." Lawyers know the risk. I see five reasons it persists.

  1. Fluency feels like accuracy. 🧠 Generative AI writes with confidence. Polished prose triggers what researchers call automation bias. We trust output that sounds right. A quotation that reads like appellate language feels authentic, even when no judge ever wrote it.

  2. Time pressure is the reason, not the excuse. ⏰ Solo and small-firm lawyers juggle emergency motions, clients in crisis, and thin margins. AI promises relief. But "time pressure" is exactly when verification gets skipped. That is when errors reach the court.

  3. Length looks like effort. 📄 AI makes pages cheap. A judge's time is not. Some lawyers seem to believe more pages signal more advocacy. Courts disagree. Volume without judgment is the very definition of slop.

  4. "The case exists" is not verification. 🔍 Many lawyers now check that a cited case is real. Fewer confirm that the case says what the brief claims, word for word. The Florida opinion shows this gap clearly. Real cases, wrong quotation, same professional failure. I addressed a related blind spot in "MTC: When Reputable Databases Fail: What Lawyers Must Do After AI Hallucinations Reach the Court."

  5. Some lawyers do not know what they do not know. 🎓 Many practitioners learned AI from marketing, not training. They see a tool, not a duty. That is why the court's closing line matters. The most dangerous lawyer is not the one who makes a mistake. It is the one who believes the practice is acceptable.

The ABA Model Rules Already Answer This 📜

lawyers should scruitinize their use of ai like their license depends on it.

The Florida referral will be judged under the Rules Regulating The Florida Bar. Still, the ABA Model Rules frame the same duties every lawyer carries.

ABA Formal Opinion 512 (July 2024) puts it plainly. Lawyers using generative AI must understand its capabilities and limits. They must also independently review its output. As I said in "MTC: Even Though AI Hallucinations Are Down: Lawyers Still Must Verify AI, Guard PII, and Follow ABA Ethics Rules," fewer errors do not mean zero errors.

A Practical Checklist for Monday Morning ✅

lawyers need to balance Innovation With Professional Responsibility

  • Read every authority you cite. Pull it from a trusted database or official reporter yourself.

  • Copy quotations from the source, never from the AI draft. Then compare them word for word.

  • Cite the record precisely. Unofficial or rough transcripts deserve a clear caveat.

  • Edit for length. Ask what the judge actually needs to rule. Then cut the rest. ✂️

  • Build a verification buffer into deadlines. Emergency filings need more review, not less.

  • Adopt a written firm AI policy. It should cover approved tools, review steps, and supervision.

  • Check your court's standing orders. Many judges now require AI-use disclosures, as I discussed in "MTC: AI in Court Filings: What Now Are Judges Now Scrutinizing Lawyers and Pro Se Litigants About AI Use."

Final Thoughts 💡

AI slop stays on the front page because it keeps happening. Each new opinion erodes the bar's credibility. The fix is not to abandon AI. It is to treat AI output like a first-year associate's rough draft: useful, fast, and never filed without a careful lawyer's review. 🤝

The lesson remains the same:  “Review, Review, Review” your work before you file! 😯

Happy Lawyering! ⚖️

MTC

MTC: How Should Lawyers Bill for AI? Time, Tokens, Overhead, and Flat Fees Under ABA Formal Opinion 512 ⚖️🤖

Matter-specific AI costs: bill actual, metered expenses transparently.

Every lawyer using AI eventually faces the same question at invoice time. 🧾 The draft took eight minutes instead of three hours. The research platform charged a premium for its AI tier. The e-discovery vendor billed by the token. So what goes on the client's bill?

The good news is that the ethics rules already answer most of this. They simply ask us to think more carefully. ABA Formal Opinion 512, issued July 29, 2024, applies Model Rule 1.5 directly to generative AI. There is no AI exception. Your fees and expenses must be reasonable. You must also explain how you charge before or within a reasonable time after the representation begins. 📜

Let's walk through several billing option lawyers are considering and see which ones hold up.

Option 1: Billing the AI's "Time" as Your Time ❌

This one is the easiest to reject. AI does not have billable hours. You do. Opinion 512 is blunt: lawyers who bill hourly "must bill for their actual time." If you spend 15 minutes crafting a prompt and 45 minutes reviewing the output, you bill one hour. You do not bill the three hours the task "used to take."

Billing phantom hours is not a gray area. It violates Rule 1.5(a). It may also implicate Rule 8.4(c), which prohibits dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation. 🚫 Watch your AI-powered timekeeping tools, too. Auto-generated time entries are suggestions. Verify them before they reach the client.

Remember the flip side. Your verification time is real legal work. Checking citations, testing the analysis against the record, and editing for judgment are all billable. Under Rules 1.1 and 3.3, that review is not optional anyway. I made this point in MTC: Even Though AI Hallucinations Are Down: Lawyers STILL MUST Verify AI, Guard PII, and Follow ABA Ethics Rules. ✅

Option 2: Absorbing AI Costs as Overhead 🏢

AI legal review: verify citations and bill actual lawyer time.

For most solo and small-firm lawyers, this is the default answer. Opinion 512 treats tools that function like "equipping and maintaining a legal practice" as overhead. Think of Microsoft 365 Copilot, the AI features inside your practice-management software, or a general-purpose ChatGPT or Claude subscription. You would not bill a client for your word processor. You should not bill them for its AI assistant either, absent advance disclosure and agreement.

Many of these features arrive quietly through software updates. I explored that problem in TSL Labs! MTC: The Hidden AI Crisis in Legal Practice: Why Lawyers Must Unmask Embedded Intelligence Before It's Too Late! If you did not know the AI was running, you cannot justify charging for it. 🕵️

Option 3: Passing Through Access Fees and Token Costs 🔢

AI subscriptions are overhead, not charges passed to clients.

Here the analysis shifts. Opinion 512 offers a helpful example. A lawyer uses a third-party AI service to review thousands of contracts for one client. The vendor charges per use. Billing the client for that actual out-of-pocket cost is ordinarily reasonable.

The key words are matter-specific, metered, and actual. If you need a refresher on how tokens drive AI pricing, see my Word of the Week: What Is a "Token" in AI Parlance? Token usage can be tracked to a specific matter. That makes it look more like a deposition transcript than office rent. 📊

Three guardrails apply:

  1. Bill the actual cost. Do not add a surcharge without clear advance disclosure.

  2. Pass along discounts. If the vendor gives you a volume rate, the client gets it too.

  3. Do not double-dip. If a subscription is already overhead, you cannot also charge per-matter "AI fees" for the same tool.

What about proprietary or in-house AI tools? Absent an agreement, Opinion 512 permits the direct cost plus a reasonable allocation of expenses directly tied to providing the tool. Appropriate disclosure is still required.

Option 4: Flat Fees and Value-Based Pricing 💡

AI competence and disclosure: protect confidentiality, earn client trust.

Flat fees reward efficiency. That is why many observers see AI as the push the billable hour has long needed. My TSL.P Labs episode, Why 96% AI Accuracy Still Fails Lawyers: Ethics, Hallucinations, and the Future of the Billable Hour, explores this tension. So does my shout-out, AI Revolution Challenges Legal Billing: Steve Embry Exposes Shadow AI Use Crisis in Law Firms.

But flat fees are not a loophole. Opinion 512 warns that charging the same flat fee may be unreasonable if AI lets you finish much faster. In its words, "A fee charged for which little or no work was performed is an unreasonable fee." The Rule 1.5(a) factors still govern. They include the skill required, the novelty of the issues, your experience, the results obtained, and the customary fee in your market.

The ethical approach is to price the value of your judgment. A will, a demand letter, or a VA supplemental claim has value because of your expertise. Its value does not come from the minutes on the clock. Set the price on that basis. Then reassess when AI materially changes your workload. Some commentators, writing in ABA Law Practice Today, argue that Opinion 512 applies Rule 1.5 too rigidly. They may be right. Until the guidance evolves, reasonableness remains the test. ⚖️

What You Cannot Bill: Your Learning Curve 🎓

Learning AI is part of your Rule 1.1 duty of technological competence under Comment 8. It is not client work. Opinion 512 says you generally cannot bill for it. The narrow exception applies when a client specifically asks you to use a particular tool. Then you may charge for learning that tool.

Disclosure Ties It All Together 🤝

Rule 1.5(b) requires you to communicate the basis of your fees and expenses, preferably in writing. Rule 1.4 requires reasonable consultation about the means you use. Rule 1.6 may require informed consent before you enter confidential information into certain tools, especially self-learning ones. Rules 5.1 and 5.3 require partners and supervisors to set firm-wide AI billing policies and train staff on them. 🔐

Practically, add a short AI paragraph to your engagement letter. Identify which tools are overhead. Identify which matter-specific AI costs, if any, will pass through at cost. Confirm that hourly entries reflect actual lawyer time only. Sample language might read: "The firm uses AI tools as part of its general overhead at no added charge. If your matter requires a specialized, usage-based AI service, we will tell you in advance and bill only its actual cost." ✍️ Clients appreciate that candor. It also protects you in a fee dispute.

My Two Cents: A Simple Framework ✅

Value-based AI billing: charge for legal judgment, not saved hours.

Here is how I apply all of this:

  • General AI tools → Overhead. Absorb them. 🏢

  • Matter-specific, metered AI services → Pass through at actual cost, disclosed in writing. 🔢

  • Your prompting and review time → Bill it accurately if you bill hourly. ⏱️

  • Time the AI saved → Belongs to the client under hourly billing. 🤝

  • Repeatable, AI-enhanced tasks → Consider a reasonable, value-based flat fee. 💡

  • Your learning curve → Your investment, not the client's. 🎓

  • Put your AI costs terms in your engagement letters → The last thing you need is a fee/cost dispute with your clients! 😤

AI changes how fast we work. It does not change who we work for. 💼 Price your judgment. Disclose your costs. Never bill a machine's minutes as your own.

MTC

Happy Lawyering!

📖 Word of the Week: “Cross‑Tenant” Learning in Legal Practice

Cross-tenant learning helps law firms improve AI tools without exposing data

If your firm uses cloud‑based tools, you are already living in a multi‑tenant world. In that world, cross‑tenant learning is quickly becoming a key concept that every lawyer and legal operations professional should understand. 🧠⚖️

In simple terms, a “tenant” is your firm’s logically separate space inside a cloud platform: your own users, matters, documents, and settings, isolated from everyone else’s. Cross‑tenant learning refers to techniques in which a vendor’s system learns from patterns across multiple tenants (for example, many law firms) to improve its features—such as search, drafting suggestions, or document classification—without exposing any other firm’s confidential data to you or yours to them.

Why cross‑tenant learning matters for law firms

Cross‑tenant learning is especially relevant as generative AI and machine‑learning tools become embedded in e‑discovery platforms, contract review tools, legal research systems, and practice‑management software. Vendors may use aggregated and anonymized usage data to:

  • Improve relevance of search results and recommendations.

  • Enhance clause and issue spotting in contracts and briefs.

  • Reduce false positives in e‑discovery or compliance alerts.

  • Optimize workflows based on how similar firms use the product.

For lawyers, the value proposition is straightforward: your tools can become “smarter” faster, based on lessons learned across many organizations, not just your own firm’s experience. Done properly, cross‑tenant learning can raise the baseline quality and efficiency of technology available to your practice. ⚙️📈

ABA Model Rules: Confidentiality and Competence

Any discussion of cross‑tenant learning for law firms must start with confidentiality and competence.

  • Model Rule 1.6 (Confidentiality of Information) requires lawyers to safeguard information relating to the representation of a client. That obligation extends to how your vendors collect, store, and use your data. You must understand whether and how client data may be used for cross‑tenant learning and ensure that any such use preserves confidentiality through anonymization, aggregation, and strong technical and contractual controls. 🔐

  • Model Rule 1.1 (Competence), including Comment 8, emphasizes that lawyers should keep abreast of the benefits and risks associated with relevant technology. Understanding cross‑tenant learning is now part of that duty. You do not need to become a data scientist, but you should be comfortable asking vendors precise questions and recognizing red flags.

  • Model Rule 5.3 (Responsibilities Regarding Nonlawyer Assistance) applies when you rely on vendors as nonlawyer assistants. You must make reasonable efforts to ensure that their conduct is compatible with your professional obligations, including how they use your data for cross‑tenant learning. 🧾

Key questions to ask your vendors

ABA Model Rules guide ethical use of cross-tenant learning technologies

When evaluating a product that relies on cross‑tenant learning, consider asking:

  1. What data is used?

    • Is it only metadata or usage logs, or are actual document contents included?

    • Is the data aggregated and anonymized before it is used to train shared models?

  1. How is confidentiality protected?

    • Can other tenants ever see prompts, documents, or client‑identifying information from our firm?

    • What technical measures (encryption, access controls, tenant isolation) are in place?

  1. Can cross‑tenant learning be limited or disabled?

    • Do we have opt‑out or configuration controls?

    • Is there a dedicated model or environment for our firm if needed?

  1. What do the contract and policies say?

    • Does the MSA or DPA clearly limit use of client data to defined purposes?

    • How long is data retained, and how is it deleted if we leave?

These questions are not merely IT concerns; they go directly to your obligations under the ABA Model Rules and your firm’s risk profile.

Practical examples in law practice

Consider a cloud‑based contract‑analysis platform used by hundreds of firms. Over time, the provider can see which clauses lawyers routinely flag as risky, which edits are typically made, and what becomes the “preferred” language for certain issues. Through cross‑tenant learning, the system can use that aggregated knowledge to highlight problematic clauses and suggest alternatives more accurately for everyone.

Another example is an e‑discovery platform that uses cross‑tenant learning to distinguish between truly relevant documents and common “noise” such as automatically generated emails. The more matters the system processes across different tenants, the better it gets at ranking documents and reducing review burdens. This can be a material efficiency gain for litigation teams. ⚖️💼

In both scenarios, your ethical comfort depends on whether underlying data is appropriately anonymized, compartmentalized, and contractually protected.

Governance steps for your firm

To align cross‑tenant learning with professional obligations, firms can:

  • Update vendor‑due‑diligence checklists to include explicit questions about cross‑tenant learning, training data use, and model isolation.

  • Involve a cross‑functional team—lawyers, IT, information security, and risk management—in vendor selection and review.

  • Document your analysis of vendor practices and how they satisfy confidentiality, competence, and supervision obligations under the ABA Model Rules.

  • Educate lawyers and staff about how AI‑enabled tools work, what kinds of data they send into the system, and how to avoid unnecessary exposure of client‑identifying details.

Takeaway for busy practitioners

Smart vendor questions reduce risk in cross-tenant legal technology adoption

You do not need to reject cross‑tenant learning to protect your clients. Instead, you should approach it as a powerful capability that demands informed oversight. When well‑implemented, cross‑tenant learning can help your firm deliver faster, more consistent, and more cost‑effective legal services, while still honoring confidentiality and ethical duties. When poorly explained or loosely governed, it becomes an unnecessary and avoidable risk.

Understanding how your tools learn—and from whom—is now part of competent, modern legal practice. ⚖️💡

MTC: Lawyers and AI Oversight: What the VA’s Patient Safety Warning Teaches About Ethical Law Firm Technology Use! ⚖️🤖

Human-in-the-loop is the point: Effective oversight happens where AI meets care—aligning clinical judgment, privacy, and compliance with real-world workflows.

The Department of Veterans Affairs’ experience with generative AI is not a distant government problem; it is a mirror held up to every law firm experimenting with AI tools for drafting, research, and client communication. I recently listened to an interview by Terry Gerton of the Federal News Network of Charyl Mason, Inspector General of the Department of Veterans Affairs, “VA rolled out new AI tools quickly, but without a system to catch mistakes, patient safety is on the line” and gained some insights on how lawyers can learn from this perhaps hastilly impliment AI program. VA clinicians are using AI chatbots to document visits and support clinical decisions, yet a federal watchdog has warned that there is no formal mechanism to identify, track, or resolve AI‑related risks—a “potential patient safety risk” created by speed without governance. In law, that same pattern translates into “potential client safety and justice risk,” because the core failure is identical: deploying powerful systems without a structured way to catch and correct their mistakes.

The oversight gap at the VA is striking. There is no standardized process for reporting AI‑related concerns, no feedback loop to detect patterns, and no clearly assigned responsibility for coordinating safety responses across the organization. Clinicians may have helpful tools, but the institution lacks the governance architecture that turns “helpful” into “reliably safe.” When law firms license AI research platforms, enable generative tools in email and document systems, or encourage staff to “try out” chatbots on live matters without written policies, risk registers, or escalation paths, they recreate that same governance vacuum. If no one measures hallucinations, data leakage, or embedded bias in outputs, risk management has given way to wishful thinking.

Existing ethics rules already tell us why that is unacceptable. Under ABA Model Rule 1.1, competence now includes understanding the capabilities and limitations of AI tools used in practice, or associating with someone who does. Model Rule 1.6 requires lawyers to critically evaluate what client information is fed into self‑learning systems and whether informed consent is required, particularly when providers reuse inputs for training. Model Rules 5.1, 5.2, and 5.3 extend these obligations across partners, supervising lawyers, and non‑lawyer staff: if a supervised lawyer or paraprofessional relies on AI in a way that undermines client protection, firm leadership cannot plausibly claim ignorance. And rules on candor to tribunals make clear that “the AI drafted it” is never a defense to filing inaccurate or fictitious authority.

Explaining the algorithm to decision-makers: Oversight means making AI risks understandable to judges, boards, and the public—clearly and credibly.

What the VA story adds is a vivid reminder that effective AI oversight is a system, not a slogan. The inspector general emphasized that AI can be “a helpful tool” only if it is paired with meaningful human engagement: defined review processes, clear routes for reporting concerns, and institutional learning from near misses. For law practice, that points directly toward structured workflows. AI‑assisted drafts should be treated as hypotheses, not answers. Reasonable human oversight includes verifying citations, checking quotations against original sources, stress‑testing legal conclusions, and documenting that review—especially in high‑stakes matters involving liberty, benefits, regulatory exposure, or professional discipline.

For lawyers with limited to moderate tech skills, this should not be discouraging; done correctly, AI governance actually makes technology more approachable. You do not need to understand model weights or training architectures to ask practical questions: What data does this tool see? When has it been wrong in the past? Who is responsible for catching those errors before they reach a client, a court, or an opposing party? Thoughtful prompts, standardized checklists for reviewing AI output, and clear sign‑off requirements are all well within reach of every practitioner.

The VA’s experience also highlights the importance of mapping AI uses and classifying their risk. In health care, certain AI use cases are obviously safety‑critical; in law, the parallel category includes anything that could affect a person’s freedom, immigration status, financial security, public benefits, or professional license. Those use cases merit heightened safeguards: tighter access control, narrower scoping of AI tasks, periodic sampling of outputs for quality, and specific training for the lawyers who use them. Importantly, this is not a “big‑law only” discipline. Solo and small‑firm lawyers can implement proportionate governance with simple written policies, matter‑level notes showing how AI was used, and explicit conversations with clients where appropriate.

Critically, AI does not dilute core professional responsibility. If a generative system inserts fictitious cases into a brief or subtly mischaracterizes a statute, the duty of candor and competence still rests squarely on the attorney who signs the work product. The VA continues to hold clinicians responsible for patient care decisions, even when AI is used as a support tool; the law should be no different. That reality should inform how lawyers describe AI use in engagement letters, how they supervise junior lawyers and staff, and how they respond when AI‑related concerns arise. In some situations, meeting ethical duties may require forthright client communication, corrective filings, and revisions to internal policies.

AI oversight starts at the desk: Lawyers must be able to interrogate model outputs, data quality, and risk signals—before technology impacts patient care.

The practical lesson from the VA’s AI warning is straightforward. The “human touch” in legal technology is not a nostalgic ideal; it is the safety mechanism that makes AI ethically usable at all. Lawyers who embrace AI while investing in governance—policies, training, and oversight calibrated to risk—will be best positioned to align with the ABA’s evolving guidance, satisfy courts and regulators, and preserve hard‑earned client trust. Those who treat AI as a magic upgrade and skip the hard work of oversight are, knowingly or not, accepting that their clients may become the test cases that reveal where the system fails. In a profession grounded in judgment, the real innovation is not adopting AI; it is designing a practice where human judgment still has the final word.

MTC